Products

Specialty Chocolate
Everyday Sweets
116 products

116 products

Quick view
Cinnamon Jelly Hearts
$3.00
Quick view
Cookie Butter Cups
$23.50
Quick view
Cookie Crumb Balls
$3.25
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Bar
$1.50
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Bark
$23.50
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Break-up Bar
from $11.75
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Caramels
from $11.00
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Clusters
from $6.75
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans
$4.50
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels
from $1.80
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Melt-a-Way
from $10.50
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Miniature Flat Chocolate Pieces #73
$6.00
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Miniatures
$6.00
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Nut Bark
$23.50
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Nut Cups
from $11.75
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Nut Cups
from $11.75
Quick view
Fluffer Nutter Candy
$2.50
Quick view
Freedom Gummi Bears
$3.00
Quick view
Fruit Jelly Beans
$3.60
Quick view
Gift Card (Online Redemption Only)
from $10.00
Cinnamon Jelly Hearts

Cinnamon Jelly Hearts

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/

Sugar and spice, our cinnamon jelly hearts are especially nice for those who prefer a little heat with their sweet. (12 oz. bag)

stefanelli's cookie butter cups

Cookie Butter Cups

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/
Cookie butter — shortbread cookie crumbs, butter, flour, and sugar formed into spreadable delight — form the core of our Cookie Butter Cups.
Cookie Crumb Balls

Cookie Crumb Balls

$3.25 Save $-3.25
/
stefanelli's dark chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars
stefanelli's dark chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars

Dark Chocolate Bar

$1.50 Save $-1.50
/

Savor Stefanelli's Dark Chocolate by itself in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. (But you'll find that's impossible!)

stefanelli's dark chocolate bark

Dark Chocolate Bark

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/

Snap yourself off a piece of our decadent dark chocolate bark. Plain for the chocolate connoisseur. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's dark chocolate break-up bar

Dark Chocolate Break-up Bar

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

Portion control made easy? Our dark chocolate Break-up Bars break apart into even sections so you can properly pace yourself (or not). Sold per pound.

stefanelli's dark chocolate caramels

Dark Chocolate Caramels

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/

Our specialty soft caramels sold by the pound. Varieties include Dark Chocolate Caramel, Dark Chocolate Caramel Nut and Salted Dark Chocolate Caramel.

stefanelli's dark chocolate clusters

Dark Chocolate Clusters

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

Our "clusters" are chock full of nuts and covered with our smooth dark chocolate. Guaranteed a nut in every bite! Walnut, Cashew, Coconut, and Toasted Coconut in dark chocolate. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's dark chocolate covered espresso beans

Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

$4.50 Save $-4.50
/

Enjoy bold, roasty coffeeshop flavor in a 4 oz. bag. Indulge in our Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans.

stefanelli's dark chocolate covered pretzels

Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels

$1.80 Save $-1.80
/

Our Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels combine a sweet and salty flavor for a timeless appeal.

stefanelli's dark chocolate melt-a-way
stefanelli's pecan dark chocolate melt-a-way
stefanelli's dark chocolate melt-a-way
stefanelli's pecan dark chocolate melt-a-way

Dark Chocolate Melt-a-Way

$10.50 Save $-10.50
/

Specially crafted for unbelievable melt-in-your-mouth texture, our Melt-a-Ways are among our most popular items. Choose from Plain Dark Chocolate, Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate, or Mint Dark Chocolate.

Dark Chocolate Miniature Flat Chocolate Pieces #73

Dark Chocolate Miniature Flat Chocolate Pieces #73

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

4.0 ounce bag of miniature solid dark chocolate pieces

stefanelli's dark chocolate miniatures

Dark Chocolate Miniatures

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk, dark, or white chocolate. Available in a 4 oz. bag.

stefanelli's dark chocolate nut bark

Dark Chocolate Nut Bark

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/

You'll go nuts for our sumptuously snappy chocolate bark, available in the following varieties: Dark chocolate — Almond and Mixed.
Sold per pound.

stefanelli's dark chocolate nut cups

Dark Chocolate Nut Cups

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

 Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in dark or milk chocolate.

stefanelli's dark chocolate nut cups

Dark Chocolate Nut Cups

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

 Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in dark chocolate.

stefanelli's fluffer nutter candy

Fluffer Nutter Candy

$2.50 Save $-2.50
/

This is our "new" must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow.
Sold per piece.

Freedom Gummi Bears

Freedom Gummi Bears

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/
Fruit Jelly Beans

Fruit Jelly Beans

$3.60 Save $-3.60
/

A 12 ounce bag of fruit jelly beans

Gift Card (Online Redemption Only)

Gift Card (Online Redemption Only)

$10.00 Save $-10.00
/

Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give them? Give them the gift of choice with a Stefanelli's Candies gift card.

Gift cards are delivered by email and contain instructions to redeem them at checkout. Gift cards must be used online, store pickup is available. Our gift cards have no additional processing fees.