all

Specialty Chocolate
Everyday Sweets
Seasonal
99 products

99 products

Quick view
Fluffer Nutter Candy
$2.50
Quick view
Cinnamon Jelly Beans
$3.60
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Covered Animal Crackers
$5.50
Quick view
Bridge Mix
$4.50
Quick view
Gummy Bears
$3.00
Quick view
Buttermints
$3.00
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Miniatures
$6.00
Quick view
Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat
from $11.75
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Coconut Logs
from $11.75
Sold Out
Chocolate Covered Marshmallows
$1.90
Quick view
Cashew Brittle
$6.00
Sold Out
Krispie Milk Chocolate Signature Bar
$1.50
Quick view
Black Licorice Jelly Beans
$3.80
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Bark
from $11.75
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Signature Bar
$1.50
Quick view
Peanut Brittle
$6.00
Quick view
Licorice Mix
$2.00
Quick view
Solid Milk Chocolate Candy Bar
$4.25
Quick view
Krispie Bark
from $11.75
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans
$4.50
stefanelli's fluffer nutter candy

Fluffer Nutter Candy

$2.50 Save $-2.50
/

This is our "new" must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow.
Sold per piece.

Cinnamon Jelly Beans

Cinnamon Jelly Beans

$3.60 Save $-3.60
/

Cinnamon jelly beans for your holiday candy dish. Available in a 12oz. bag.

stefanelli's milk chocolate covered animal crackers

Milk Chocolate Covered Animal Crackers

$5.50 Save $-5.50
/
Embrace your inner child with crispy animal crackers coated in milk chocolate. Available in 4oz package.
stefanelli's bridge mix

Bridge Mix

$4.50 Save $-4.50
/

Snack on an assortment of chocolate-covered almonds, brazils, creams, malt balls, peanuts and raisins.  Sold in a 12 oz. bag.

stefanelli's gummy bears

Gummy Bears

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/

Our small, fruit flavored Gummy Bears are soft and sweet. Enjoy a 12 oz. bag of our Gummy Bears.

stefanelli's buttermints

Buttermints

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/

Old-fashioned, buttery, sweet, minty candy - our buttermints are available in an 8 oz. bag.

stefanelli's milk chocolate miniatures

Milk Chocolate Miniatures

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk chocolate. Available in a 4oz. bag.

stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted nougat

Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/

Soft, whipped nougat encased in a milk chocolate shell available in Plain, Cherry, or Raspberry flavors.

stefanelli's milk chocolate coconut logs

Milk Chocolate Coconut Logs

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

For the coconut lovers in the bunch! Chewy coconut centers enrobed in creamy milk chocolate. Coconut Joy has the added touch of an almond placed on top! Sold per pound.

Cashew Brittle

Cashew Brittle

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

Stefanelli's homemade Cashew Brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted cashews in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4oz bag.

Black Licorice Jelly Beans

Black Licorice Jelly Beans

$3.80 Save $-3.80
/

Black licorice jelly beans make the perfect sweet snack for your holiday candy dish. Available in a 12 oz. bag.

stefanelli's milk chocolate bark

Milk Chocolate Bark

$23.50 Save $-23.50
/

Unadulterated milk chocolate at its finest, with a subtle snap to keep you coming back. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's dark chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars
stefanelli's dark chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars

Dark Chocolate Signature Bar

$1.50 Save $-1.50
/

Savor Stefanelli's Dark Chocolate by itself in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. (But you'll find that's impossible!)

stefanelli's peanut brittle

Peanut Brittle

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

Stefanelli's homemade Peanut Brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted peanuts in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4oz bag.

stefanelli's licorice mix

Licorice Mix

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/

With a variety of assorted licorice pieces, this bag of licorice allsorts is the perfect confection for any licorice lover! Available in a 6 oz. bag. 

stefanelli's solid milk chocolate candy bar

Solid Milk Chocolate Candy Bar

$4.25 Save $-4.25
/

Solid 3-oz. milk chocolate candy bar, stamped with the Stefanelli's Candies insignia. 

stefanelli's krispie bark

Krispie Bark

$11.75 Save $-11.75
/

Crisped rice infused into sheets of creamy milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's milk chocolate covered espresso beans

Milk Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

$4.50 Save $-4.50
/

Enjoy bold, roasty coffeeshop flavor in a 4 oz. bag. Indulge in our Milk Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans.