Products

Specialty Chocolate
Everyday Sweets
Seasonal Candy
137 products

137 products

Quick view
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
$35.00
Quick view
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
$25.00
Quick view
Advent Calendar
$13.25
Quick view
Almond Toffee Bark
$21.00
Quick view
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
$18.25
Quick view
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz
$10.50
Sold Out
Assorted Jellies
$21.00
Quick view
Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat
from $11.00
Sold Out
Bag O' Ghosts
$4.15
Quick view
Bridge Mix
$4.00
Quick view
Build A Box
$24.00
Quick view
Buttermints
$2.75
Quick view
Caramel Santa Smidgens
$5.00
Quick view
Cashew Brittle
$5.50
Quick view
Cherry Cordials
$20.00
Quick view
Chocolate Buckeye
$21.00
Quick view
Chocolate Covered Almonds
$3.95
Quick view
Chocolate Covered Cashews
$3.95
Quick view
Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers
$1.35
Quick view
Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzels
$2.50
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)
12" Cocoa Pie (Large)

12" Cocoa Pie (Large)

$35.00 Save $-35.00
/

 

  • Campfire - Chocolate Dough, Graham Crackers, Chocolate Bark Chunks, Mini Marshmallows, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Movie Night - Chocolate Dough, Popcorn, Peanuts, M&M's, Milk Chocolate Drizzle

  • Piggy Yolks & Taters - Chocolate Dough, Gummy Eggs, Bacon, Potato Chips, Milk Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Cookie Craze - Chocolate Dough, Oreo, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Nutter Butters, Brownie Bites, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • 'Toad'ally Turtle - Chocolate Dough, Pecans, Salted Cashews, Caramel Drizzle, Milke & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Happy Birthday Bash - Chocolate Dough, Ice Cream Cone, Krispie Ice Cream Ball Dipped in White Chocolate with Sprinkles Upsidedown on Dough, Sprinkle Edge 'Crust'.

  • Peanutty Peanut Butter - Peanut Butter Chip Dough, Reese Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Darkest Delight - Dark Chocolate Dough.



9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)
9" Cocoa Pie (Small)

9" Cocoa Pie (Small)

$25.00 Save $-25.00
/

 

  • Campfire - Chocolate Dough, Graham Crackers, Chocolate Bark Chunks, Mini Marshmallows, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Movie Night - Chocolate Dough, Popcorn, Peanuts, M&M's, Milk Chocolate Drizzle

  • Piggy Yolks & Taters - Chocolate Dough, Gummy Eggs, Bacon, Potato Chips, Milk Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Cookie Craze - Chocolate Dough, Oreo, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Nutter Butters, Brownie Bites, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • 'Toad'ally Turtle - Chocolate Dough, Pecans, Salted Cashews, Caramel Drizzle, Milke & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Happy Birthday Bash - Chocolate Dough, Ice Cream Cone, Krispie Ice Cream Ball Dipped in White Chocolate with Sprinkles Upsidedown on Dough, Sprinkle Edge 'Crust'.

  • Peanutty Peanut Butter - Peanut Butter Chip Dough, Reese Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.

  • Darkest Delight - Dark Chocolate Dough.



Advent Calendar

Advent Calendar

$13.25 Save $-13.25
/
Counting down the weeks til Christmas is a lot easier when you take it one melt-in-your-mouth day at a time.
stefanelli's almond toffee bark

Almond Toffee Bark

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/

Our Almond Toffee Bark enfolds buttery, crunchy toffee and almonds into rich milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb

$18.25 Save $-18.25
/

Watch them light up when they receive this tantalizing assortment of caramels, cremes, nuts, and more!

(Please Note: Lids may vary!)

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz

$10.50 Save $-10.50
/

Mistletoe or no, you can expect to quickly kiss this half-pound assortment of our best chocolates good-bye.

(Please note: Lids may vary!)

stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted milk chocolate nougat
stefanelli's assorted nougat

Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/

Soft, whipped nougat encased in a milk chocolate shell available in Plain, Cherry, or Raspberry flavors.

stefanelli's bridge mix

Bridge Mix

$4.00 Save $-4.00
/

Snack on an assortment of chocolate-covered almonds, brazils, creams, malt balls, peanuts and raisins.  Sold in a 12 oz. bag.

stefanelli's build a box chocolate variety

Build A Box

$24.00 Save $-24.00
/
Design your own box of chocolates for yourself or someone you know! This box includes 30 pcs of “customers choice” of five different varieties. Price reflects customization costs.
stefanelli's buttermints

Buttermints

$2.75 Save $-2.75
/

Old-fashioned, buttery, sweet, minty candy - our buttermints are available in an 8 oz. bag.

Caramel Santa Smidgens

Caramel Santa Smidgens

$5.00 Save $-5.00
/

Christmas themed Caramel Smidgens 4.0 oz.

Cashew Brittle

Cashew Brittle

$5.50 Save $-5.50
/

Stefanelli's homemade Cashew Brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted cashews in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4oz bag.

stefanelli's cherry cordials

Cherry Cordials

$20.00 Save $-20.00
/

Rich milk chocolate surrounds a luscious cherry center. Each pound of Cherry Cordials is sold in our classic giftbox.

Chocolate Buckeye

Chocolate Buckeye

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/
Our take on the Midwestern favorite features creamy peanut butter (mostly) enrobed in smooth milk chocolate.
stefanelli's chocolate covered almonds

Chocolate Covered Almonds

$3.95 Save $-3.95
/

Chocolate-covered almonds in delicious milk chocolate. Available in 3oz bag.

stefanelli's chocolate covered cashews

Chocolate Covered Cashews

$3.95 Save $-3.95
/

Chocolate-covered cashews in our delicious milk chocolate. Available in 3oz bag.

stefanelli's chocolate covered graham crackers

Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers

$1.35 Save $-1.35
/
Milk chocolate and crispy, honey-kissed Graham cracker unite for the classic campfire companion. Just add marshmallow. 1 per pack.
stefanelli's chocolate covered holiday pretzels

Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzels

$2.50 Save $-2.50
/

Our popular milk chocolate covered pretzels dressed in their holiday best — a robe of fine chocolate, accessorized with festive candy sprinkles. Available in a 2.4oz bag.