All Chocolate and Candies

JUMBO Homemade Peanut Butter Cup! More than a mouthful of rich, creamy peanut butter to fill you up.

With a variety of assorted licorice pieces, this bag of licorice allsorts is the perfect confection for any licorice lover! Available in a 6 oz. bag. 

Homemade marshmallow with a touch of vanilla, blanketed in milk chocolate. A true customer favorite!

Our homemade old-fashioned buttery toffee candy with crushed almond offered in Milk Chocolate. Priced per pound.

A delicious assortment of our finest chocolates. An afternoon pick-me-up or a thoughtful gift available in all the right sizes!

Unadulterated milk chocolate at its finest, with a subtle snap to keep you coming back. Sold per pound.

Our specialty soft caramels sold by the pound. Varieties include Milk Chocolate Caramel, Salted Milk Chocolate Caramel, Milk Chocolate Caramel Nut, and Milk Chocolate Salted Caramel Nut.

Our "clusters" are chock full of nuts and covered with our smooth milk chocolate. Guaranteed a nut in every bite! 

Embrace your inner child with crispy animal crackers coated in milk chocolate. Available in 4oz package.

An assortment of Stefanelli's creamy milk chocolate married with your favorite smooth cream centers - tropical coconut, classic Florida orange, citrus lemon cream, traditional maple, and so many more.

Choose from one or two pounds of our assorted milk chocolate covered nuts.

You'll go nuts for our sumptuously snappy chocolate bark, available in the following varieties: Milk chocolate — Walnut, Pecan, Almond, Cashew, and Mixed. Dark chocolate — Almond and Mixed. 
Sold per pound.

 Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in milk chocolate.

 Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in milk or dark.

Milk chocolate with our signature smooth peanut butter filling. 
Sold per pound.

These clusters are chock full of peanuts and covered in our smooth melt-in-your-mouth milk chocolate. Peanut clusters sold in 5oz. bag and available in milk chocolate only.

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Smooth, refreshing peppermint cream in a milk chocolate coating. Sold in an 8 oz. box.

Milk chocolate bark surrounds sweet, chewy raisins. Sold per pound.

Sponge Candy is Erie's signature candy and it's simply delicious. In other parts of the country it's also called seafoam, honeycomb or cinder toffee, or hokey pokey. Each bite offers the creamy smoothness of Stefanelli's Candies Milk Chocolate with the melt-away crunch of toffee filling.

Try to have just one piece!