All Chocolate and Candies

17 products

17 products

Sold Out
1 Lb. Milk Assorted Heart-Shaped Box
$30.50 $15.25 Save $15.25
Sold Out
Assorted Holiday Square Box (Asst. Milk Chocolates) - Small 3oz.
$5.75
Quick view
Candy Kabobs
$5.00
Quick view
Chocolate Covered Jellies
from $12.00
Quick view
Chocolate Miniatures
$6.25
Quick view
Daisy sucker
$2.70
Quick view
Fluffer Nutter Candy
$3.00
Quick view
Foiled Chocolate Miniature Lips
$6.00
Sold Out
Gold Foil "Happy Valentine's Day" Milk Chocolate Assortment Box
$8.00 from $4.00 Save $4.00
Quick view
Gummy Worms
$3.25
Quick view
Milk & Dark Assortment
from $21.00
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Letters
$3.00
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs
from $12.00
Quick view
Open Rose Sucker
$2.55
Quick view
Peanut Butter Cups
from $12.00
Quick view
Puzzle Piece Chocolate
$2.05
Quick view
Tulip sucker
$1.95
Candy Kabobs

Candy Kabobs

$5.00 Save $-5.00
/
*sold individually and shipped at random; candy kabobs vary between everyday & seasonally themed
Chocolate Covered Jellies

Chocolate Covered Jellies

$12.00 Save $-12.00
/
Our handmade chocolate covered Jellies are available in 3 delightful flavors and contains a dollop of fruit jelly. Flavors include: Raspberry Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), Orange Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), and Peanut Butter & Grape Jellies (available in milk chocolate only). 
stefanelli's milk chocolate miniatures

Chocolate Miniatures

$6.25 Save $-6.25
/

Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk chocolate. Available in a 4oz. bag. (not season specific)

Daisy sucker

Daisy sucker

$2.70 Save $-2.70
/

Milk Chocolate daisy sucker 1.76oz

stefanelli's fluffer nutter candy

Fluffer Nutter Candy

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/

This is our "new" must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow.
Sold per piece.

Foiled Chocolate Miniature Lips

Foiled Chocolate Miniature Lips

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/

If you're impressed with the way these milk chocolate lips shimmer in their glossy red foil, just wait — they shine even more once you taste them. (4 oz. bag)

stefanelli's gummy worms

Gummy Worms

$3.25 Save $-3.25
/

Our fruit-flavored Gummy Worms are soft and sweet. Enjoy a 12 oz. bag of our Gummy Worms.

stefanelli's milk and dark assortment

Milk & Dark Assortment

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/

One or two pounds of our delectable assorted milk and dark chocolates.

Milk Chocolate Letters

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/
Mix & Match your favorite letters to create a customizable gift that also serves as a sweet treat!
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs

Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs

$12.00 Save $-12.00
/

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Open Rose Sucker

Open Rose Sucker

$2.55 Save $-2.55
/

Milk Chocolate open rose sucker 1.6oz

stefanelli's milk chocolate peanut butter cups

Peanut Butter Cups

$12.00 Save $-12.00
/

Our homemade cups with peanut butter smoothie filling, available in milk,  dark, or white chocolate. 

Puzzle Piece Chocolate
Puzzle Piece Chocolate
Puzzle Piece Chocolate
Puzzle Piece Chocolate
Puzzle Piece Chocolate
Puzzle Piece Chocolate

Puzzle Piece Chocolate

$2.05 Save $-2.05
/

Have a piece in supporting the Autism Society of NWPA during National Autism Awareness Month in April. The society will receive $1 for each awareness sucker sold. Fundraiser dates: 3/25-4/30/24

Tulip sucker

Tulip sucker

$1.95 Save $-1.95
/

Milk Chocolate Tulip sucker 1.28oz