All Chocolate and Candies

Sponge Candy is Erie's signature candy and it's simply delicious. In other parts of the country it's also called seafoam, honeycomb or cinder toffee, or hokey pokey. Each bite offers the creamy smoothness of Stefanelli's Candies Milk Chocolate with the melt-away crunch of toffee filling.

Try to have just one piece!

Our premium soft-centered caramels, shrunken down for optimum snackability.

Milk Chocolate "Mom" plaque 6.7oz

Milk chocolate "Mom" plaque with flowers 6.4oz

A robust assortment of your favorite coffeeshop flavors encase roasted espresso beans for a boost you'll crave. Available in Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, and a NY Mix!        4 oz. bags

Plain milk chocolate discs topped with nonpareils. Available in a 4oz. box.

 Almond, Peanut and Filbert Nut Cups available in Milk Chocolate or Dark Chocolate!

Chewy, crunchy, and above all, tasty. Treat yourself to one or two pounds of our delicious assorted nuts, caramels, and nougats.

Stefanelli's homemade Peanut Brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted peanuts in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4oz bag.

Peanut butter-swirled milk chocolate bark plays host to our craveable chopped peanut butter cups. 

Our homemade cups with peanut butter smoothie filling, available in milk,  dark, or white chocolate. 

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with creamy chocolate. Sold per pound. Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate Only

Have a piece in supporting the Autism Society of NWPA during National Autism Awareness Month in April. The society will receive $1 for each awareness sucker sold. Fundraiser dates: 3/25-4/30/24

A Rocky Road Sundae on a stick! Chopped almonds and marshmallow enveloped in a crunchy chocolate shell. 

Our Signature candy bars are available in 7 delicious flavors! Flavors include: Plain Milk Chocolate, Plain Dark Chocolate, Roasted Almonds, Krispie, Creamy Caramel, Peanut Butter Smoothie, and Milk Pretzel. 1.75oz/each (Ask about fundraising opportunites!)

Solid 3-oz. chocolate bar stamped with the Stefanelli's Candies insignia. Available in Milk, Dark, & White Chocolate