Christmas Candy

If eating candy is naughty, we don’t want to be nice! Wish your family, friends, or colleagues (and don’t forget yourself!) happy holidays with Stefanelli’s Candies. Deliver a sleigh-full of cheer to holiday stockings, gift baskets, or directly to the table throughout the Christmas season. You’ll feel good about our premium ingredients and craftsmanship (even if you’ve been bad this year).
52 products

52 products

Quick view
Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs
from $14.99
Quick view
Miniature Foiled Chocolate Santas
$6.50
Quick view
Miniature Foiled Chocolate Snowmen
$6.50
Quick view
Miniature Foiled Chocolate Presents
$6.50
Quick view
Peanut Butter Smidgens
$6.50
Quick view
Miniature Foiled Chocolate Soldiers
$6.50
Quick view
Christmas Chocolate Covered Oreos
$4.25
Quick view
Miniature Foiled Chocolate Ornaments
$6.50
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Santa Lollipop
$1.55
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Snowman Cutouts
$1.90
Quick view
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece
$14.50
Quick view
Christmas Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers
$1.79
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Christmas Tree Cutouts
$1.25
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Snowman Lollipop
$1.55
Sold Out
Advent Calendar
$15.00
Quick view
Trees and Snowman
$3.50
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Santa Cutouts
$2.25
Quick view
Solid Milk Chocolate Old World Santa
$7.55
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Christmas Gift Lollipop
$1.75
Quick view
Caramel Santa Smidgens
$6.50
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs

Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs

$14.99 Save $-14.99
/

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's miniature foiled chocolate santas

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Santas

$6.50 Save $0.00
/

Our jolly little Santas are a delicious treat for your guests. Christmas Miniature Foiled Santas are sold in our 4oz bag.

stefanelli's miniature foiled chocolate snowmen

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Snowmen

$6.50 Save $-6.50
/

You'll love that these snowmen can melt in your mouth! Christmas Miniature Foiled Snowmen are available in our 4oz bag.

stefanelli's miniature foiled chocolate presents

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Presents

$6.50 Save $-6.50
/
Give the gift of chocolate with these miniature, foil-wrapped, solid milk chocolate presents.
Peanut Butter Smidgens

Peanut Butter Smidgens

$6.50 Save $-0.25
/

4oz bag of peanut butter filled (holiday themed) shapes. Seasonal for Fall/Christmas/ Easter

stefanelli's miniature chocolate foiled soldiers

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Soldiers

$6.50 Save $-0.50
/

Solid milk chocolate Miniature Soldiers in a festive Christmas foil are great stocking stuffers for those on your nice list! Available in our 4 oz bags. Items may vary by whats in stock.

stefanelli's christmas chocolate covered oreos

Christmas Chocolate Covered Oreos

$4.25 Save $-4.25
/

A pair of Chocolate Covered Oreo Cookies with an added decorative touch for Christmas. Santa would approve.

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Ornaments

Miniature Foiled Chocolate Ornaments

$6.50 Save $-0.50
/

These miniature, foil-wrapped, solid milk chocolate Christmas ornaments aren't hangable, but they're definitely craveable! (4 oz. bag)

stefanelli's milk chocolate santa lollipop

Milk Chocolate Santa Lollipop

$1.55 Save $-1.55
/
What's Santa so jolly about? Take a bite out of this solid milk chocolate Santa lollipop and the truth will become clear.
stefanelli's milk chocolate snowman cutouts

Milk Chocolate Snowman Cutouts

$1.90 Save $-1.90
/

Unlike your snowman outside, our milk chocolate snowman cutout is perfectly stable at room temperature. And way tastier. 

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece
Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 16 piece

$14.50 Save $-14.50
/

Mistletoe or no, you can expect to quickly kiss this half-pound assortment of our best chocolates good-bye.

(Please note: Lids may vary!)

stefanelli's christmas chocolate covered graham crackers

Christmas Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers

$1.79 Save $-1.79
/

Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers with a festive decorative touch. 1 per pack.

stefanelli's milk chocolate christmas tree cutouts

Milk Chocolate Christmas Tree Cutouts

$1.25 Save $-1.25
/

This tasty milk chocolate Christmas tree cutout should easily fit through your front door. And won't leave behind any needles. 

stefanelli's milk chocolate snowman lollipop

Milk Chocolate Snowman Lollipop

$1.55 Save $-1.55
/
Happy birthday! We mean, happy holidays! This chocolate snowman lollipop is the opposite of abominable, thanks to our creamy, melt-in-your-mouth milk chocolate.
Trees and Snowman

Trees and Snowman

$3.50 Save $-3.50
/

Gummy Trees and Snowman. Available in a 6oz. bag.

stefanelli's milk chocolate santa cutouts

Milk Chocolate Santa Cutouts

$2.25 Save $-2.25
/
Santa, is that you? You're looking slimmer than usual. Despite the flatness of shape, this milk chocolate Santa cutout has the same depth and roundness of flavor you can expect from Stefanelli's.
stefanelli's solid milk chocolate old world santa

Solid Milk Chocolate Old World Santa

$7.55 Save $-7.55
/

Why pull on Santa's beard when you can eat it? Our Old World-style Santa is molded from our premium 100 percent solid milk chocolate — nothing fake here! (4.85 oz.)

stefanelli's milk chocolate christmas gift lollipop

Milk Chocolate Christmas Gift Lollipop

$1.75 Save $-1.75
/
Hate when your presents melt in your hands? We do too, which is why we're serving this luscious solid milk chocolate Christmas gift on a stick, lollipop-style.
Caramel Santa Smidgens

Caramel Santa Smidgens

$6.50 Save $-6.50
/

Christmas themed Caramel Smidgens 4.0 oz.