Christmas Candy

Filter

          If eating candy is naughty, we don’t want to be nice! Wish your friends and family happy holidays with Christmas candy from Stefanelli’s, handmade in Erie, PA since 1929. Deliver a sleigh-full of cheer to stockings, gift baskets, or directly to the table all season long. 

          Need a Christmas chocolate gift box? Our festive assortments come loaded with caramels, creams, nuts, and more. For even more options, browse all of our chocolate gift boxes. And for anyone on your list who misses Erie, our famous sponge candy is the gift they’ll be most excited to unwrap!

          46 products

          46 products

          Quick view
          Christmas Sugar Cookies
          $4.50
          Quick view
          Solid Milk Chocolate Old World Santa
          $7.55
          Quick view
          Milk Chocolate Santa Cutouts
          $2.25
          Quick view
          Milk Chocolate Christmas Gift Lollipop
          $1.75
          Quick view
          Peanut Butter Smidgens
          $6.50
          Quick view
          Chocolate Covered Jellies
          from $14.99
          Quick view
          The Elfzecutive - Corporate Gift Box (Option 4)
          $45.00
          Quick view
          Milk Chocolate Candy Cane Lollipop
          $1.25
          Quick view
          Solid Milk Chocolate Santa with Floppy Hat
          $5.55
          Quick view
          Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Santa
          $3.00
          Quick view
          White Peppermint Crunch Meltaway
          $12.65
          Quick view
          Snow Days Gummies -5oz
          $3.50
          Quick view
          Large Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzel
          $1.50
          Quick view
          Christmas Tower
          $16.00
          Quick view
          The Santa Summit - Corporate Gift Box (Option 6)
          $65.00
          Quick view
          Christmas Malt Balls
          $3.00
          Quick view
          Tail Banger Dog Treats - Xmas
          $9.99
          Quick view
          Fruit Slices Acetate Circle
          $9.25
          Quick view
          Cinnamon JuJu Santas
          $4.00
          Quick view
          Milk Chocolate Wreath Lollipop
          $1.25

          Christmas Sugar Cookies

          $4.50 Save $-4.50
          /
          stefanelli's solid milk chocolate old world santa

          Solid Milk Chocolate Old World Santa

          $7.55 Save $-7.55
          /

          Why pull on Santa's beard when you can eat it? Our Old World-style Santa is molded from our premium 100 percent solid milk chocolate — nothing fake here! (4.85 oz.)

          stefanelli's milk chocolate santa cutouts

          Milk Chocolate Santa Cutouts

          $2.25 Save $-2.25
          /
          Santa, is that you? You're looking slimmer than usual. Despite the flatness of shape, this milk chocolate Santa cutout has the same depth and roundness of flavor you can expect from Stefanelli's.
          stefanelli's milk chocolate christmas gift lollipop

          Milk Chocolate Christmas Gift Lollipop

          $1.75 Save $-1.75
          /
          Hate when your presents melt in your hands? We do too, which is why we're serving this luscious solid milk chocolate Christmas gift on a stick, lollipop-style.
          Peanut Butter Smidgens

          Peanut Butter Smidgens

          $6.50 Save $-6.50
          /

          Christmas themed Peanut Butter Smidgens 4.0 oz.

          Chocolate Covered Jellies

          Chocolate Covered Jellies

          $14.99 Save $-14.99
          /

          OUT OF STOCK

          Our handmade chocolate covered Jellies are available in 3 delightful flavors and contains a dollop of fruit jelly. Flavors include: Raspberry Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), Orange Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), and Peanut Butter & Grape Jellies (available in milk chocolate only). 

          The Elfzecutive - Corporate Gift Box (Option 4)

          The Elfzecutive - Corporate Gift Box (Option 4)

          $45.00 Save $-45.00
          /
          We think your partners and clients will agree; the best kind of product portfolio is the kind you can review with your taste buds. This collection includes: 1 lb. of milk chocolate meltaways, a half-pound of assorted milk chocolates, 5 oz. of our beloved sponge candy, and a "Merry Christmas" milk chocolate bar.
          stefanelli's milk chocolate candy cane lollipop

          Milk Chocolate Candy Cane Lollipop

          $1.25 Save $-1.25
          /
          No peppermint in this candy cane lollipop, just premium Stefanelli's milk chocolate.
          stefanelli's solid milk chocolate santa with floppy hat

          Solid Milk Chocolate Santa with Floppy Hat

          $5.55 Save $-5.55
          /

          A solid milk chocolate Santa in his signature floppy hat, fresh out of Stefanelli's candy workshop.

          Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Santa

          Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Santa

          $3.00 Save $-3.00
          /

          These milk chocolaty St. Nicks are filled past their britches with creamy peanut butter. Ho, ho, hold up before you devour the entire 2 oz. in one sitting — in fact, you'd better order extra just in case! 

          White Peppermint Crunch Meltaway

          White Peppermint Crunch Meltaway

          $12.65 Save $-12.65
          /
          White Peppermint Crunch Meltaway _15pcs (seasonal peppermint candy cane meltaway)
          Snow Days Gummies -5oz

          Snow Days Gummies -5oz

          $3.50 Save $-3.50
          /
          stefanelli's large chocolate covered holiday pretzel
          stefanelli's large chocolate covered holiday pretzel
          stefanelli's large chocolate covered holiday pretzel
          stefanelli's large chocolate covered holiday pretzel

          Large Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzel

          $1.50 Save $-1.50
          /

          Measurable sprinkles have fallen on our large Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzel, adding a festive flair to this sweet and salty favorite.

          Christmas Tower

          Christmas Tower

          $16.00 Save $-16.00
          /
          The Santa Summit - Corporate Gift Box (Option 6)

          The Santa Summit - Corporate Gift Box (Option 6)

          $65.00 Save $-65.00
          /
          We're projecting growth with over 3 lbs. of our best-selling products, including: 2 lbs. of our assorted milk chocolates for crowd-pleasing variety, a half-pound of our plain milk chocolate meltaways AND a "Merry Christmas" chocolate bar for the purists in the bunch, and 5 oz. of our signature crispy, crunchy chocolate covered sponge candy. Merry Christmas to all and all a good bite!

          Christmas Malt Balls

          $3.00 Save $-3.00
          /

          Tail Banger Dog Treats - Xmas

          $9.99 Save $-9.99
          /

          Fruit Slices Acetate Circle

          $9.25 Save $-9.25
          /

          Cinnamon JuJu Santas

          $4.00 Save $-4.00
          /
          stefanelli's milk chocolate wreath lollipop

          Milk Chocolate Wreath Lollipop

          $1.25 Save $-1.25
          /
          Send a warm winter welcome this solid milk chocolate wreath lollipop.