These milk chocolaty St. Nicks are filled past their britches with creamy peanut butter. Ho, ho, hold up before you devour the entire 2 oz. in one sitting — in fact, you'd better order extra just in case!

Name

Message

Peanut Butter Smidgens

Regular price $5.50 Save $-5.50

Christmas themed Peanut Butter Smidgens 4.0 oz.

Name

Message

Caramel Santa Smidgens

Regular price $5.00 Save $-5.00

Christmas themed Caramel Smidgens 4.0 oz.

Name

Message

Solid Milk Chocolate Santa with Floppy Hat

Regular price $5.25 Save $-5.25

A solid milk chocolate Santa in his signature floppy hat, fresh out of Stefanelli's candy workshop.

Name

Message

Solid Milk Chocolate Old World Santa

Regular price $6.65 Save $-6.65

Why pull on Santa's beard when you can eat it? Our Old World-style Santa is molded from our premium 100 percent solid milk chocolate — nothing fake here! (4.85 oz.)

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Christmas Tree Cutouts

Regular price $1.10 Save $-1.10

This tasty milk chocolate Christmas tree cutout should easily fit through your front door. And won't leave behind any needles.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Snowman Cutouts

Regular price $1.65 Save $-1.65

Unlike your snowman outside, our milk chocolate snowman cutout is perfectly stable at room temperature. And way tastier.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Santa Cutouts

Regular price $1.95 Save $-1.95

Santa, is that you? You're looking slimmer than usual. Despite the flatness of shape, this milk chocolate Santa cutout has the same depth and roundness of flavor you can expect from Stefanelli's.

Name

Message

Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzels

Regular price $2.50 Save $-2.50

Our popular milk chocolate covered pretzels dressed in their holiday best — a robe of fine chocolate, accessorized with festive candy sprinkles. Available in a 2.4oz bag.

Name

Message

stefanelli's large chocolate covered holiday pretzel

Large Chocolate Covered Holiday Pretzel

Regular price $1.10 Save $-1.10

Measurable sprinkles have fallen on our large Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzel, adding a festive flair to this sweet and salty favorite.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Wreath Lollipop

Regular price $1.10 Save $-1.10

Send a warm winter welcome this solid milk chocolate wreath lollipop.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Santa Lollipop

Regular price $1.40 Save $-1.40

What's Santa so jolly about? Take a bite out of this solid milk chocolate Santa lollipop and the truth will become clear.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Candy Cane Lollipop

Regular price $1.10 Save $-1.10

No peppermint in this candy cane lollipop, just premium Stefanelli's milk chocolate.

Name

Message

Milk Chocolate Christmas Gift Lollipop

Regular price $1.55 Save $-1.55

Hate when your presents melt in your hands? We do too, which is why we're serving this luscious solid milk chocolate Christmas gift on a stick, lollipop-style.

Name

Message

Advent Calendar

Regular price $13.25 Save $-13.25

Counting down the weeks til Christmas is a lot easier when you take it one melt-in-your-mouth day at a time.

Name

Message

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 8oz

Regular price $10.50 Save $-10.50

Mistletoe or no, you can expect to quickly kiss this half-pound assortment of our best chocolates good-bye.

(Please note: Lids may vary!)

Name

Message

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 1lb

Regular price $18.25 Save $-18.25

Watch them light up when they receive this tantalizing assortment of caramels, cremes, nuts, and more!

(Please Note: Lids may vary!)

Name

Message

9" Cocoa Pie (Small)

Regular price $25.00 Save $-25.00

Campfire - Chocolate Dough, Graham Crackers, Chocolate Bark Chunks, Mini Marshmallows, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Movie Night - Chocolate Dough, Popcorn, Peanuts, M&M's, Milk Chocolate Drizzle
Piggy Yolks & Taters - Chocolate Dough, Gummy Eggs, Bacon, Potato Chips, Milk Chocolate Drizzle.
Cookie Craze - Chocolate Dough, Oreo, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Nutter Butters, Brownie Bites, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
'Toad'ally Turtle - Chocolate Dough, Pecans, Salted Cashews, Caramel Drizzle, Milke & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Happy Birthday Bash - Chocolate Dough, Ice Cream Cone, Krispie Ice Cream Ball Dipped in White Chocolate with Sprinkles Upsidedown on Dough, Sprinkle Edge 'Crust'.
Peanutty Peanut Butter - Peanut Butter Chip Dough, Reese Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Darkest Delight - Dark Chocolate Dough.

Name

Message

12" Cocoa Pie (Large)

Regular price $35.00 Save $-35.00

Campfire - Chocolate Dough, Graham Crackers, Chocolate Bark Chunks, Mini Marshmallows, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Movie Night - Chocolate Dough, Popcorn, Peanuts, M&M's, Milk Chocolate Drizzle
Piggy Yolks & Taters - Chocolate Dough, Gummy Eggs, Bacon, Potato Chips, Milk Chocolate Drizzle.
Cookie Craze - Chocolate Dough, Oreo, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Nutter Butters, Brownie Bites, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
'Toad'ally Turtle - Chocolate Dough, Pecans, Salted Cashews, Caramel Drizzle, Milke & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Happy Birthday Bash - Chocolate Dough, Ice Cream Cone, Krispie Ice Cream Ball Dipped in White Chocolate with Sprinkles Upsidedown on Dough, Sprinkle Edge 'Crust'.
Peanutty Peanut Butter - Peanut Butter Chip Dough, Reese Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips, Milk & White Chocolate Drizzle.
Darkest Delight - Dark Chocolate Dough.

Name

Message

Assorted Holiday Milk Chocolate - 3oz

Regular price $5.00 Save $-5.00

Mistletoe or no, you can expect to quickly kiss this 3oz. assortment of our best chocolates good-bye.

(Please note: Lids may vary!)

Name

Message