Any day is a good day for our Everyday Chocolate — and with Stefanelli’s robust selection of finely crafted candies, no day has to be exactly the same experience. Mix and match textures and flavors to your tastebuds’ content — or don’t. Where we come from, it’s okay to play favorites.
Soft, whipped nougat encased in a milk chocolate shell available in Plain, Cherry, or Raspberry flavors.
Pecan Frogs
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with creamy chocolate. Sold per pound. Available in Milk & Dark Chocolate Only
Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties
Regular price
$9.00
Save $-9.00
/
Smooth, refreshing peppermint cream in a dark chocolate patty. Sold in an 8 oz. box.
Milk Chocolate Letters
Regular price
$3.00
Save $-3.00
/
Mix & Match your favorite letters to create a customizable gift that also serves as a sweet treat!
Mallow Bars
Regular price
$2.60
Save $-2.60
/
Homemade marshmallow with a touch of vanilla, blanketed in milk chocolate. A true customer favorite!
Dark Chocolate Clusters
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Our "clusters" are chock full of nuts and covered with our smooth dark chocolate. Guaranteed a nut in every bite! Walnut, Cashew, Coconut, and Toasted Coconut in dark chocolate. Sold per pound.
Cashew Frogs
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
We offer a new twist on the traditional turtle. Creamy chocolate nests cozily in a caramel and cashew patty, creating an undeniable treat. Cashews Frogs are available in Milk & White Chocolate Only.
Break-up Bars
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Our Break-up Bars break apart into even sections for a convenient treat that is both delicious & portioned! Available in Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate Only. Sold per pound.
Chocolate Liquor Cups
Regular price
$0.90
Save $-0.90
/
A delicious chocolate shot glass. Bottoms up! Available in milk & dark chocolate (Weights may vary)
Chocolate Covered Jellies
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Our handmade chocolate covered Jellies are available in 3 delightful flavors and contains a dollop of fruit jelly. Flavors include: Raspberry Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), Orange Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), and Peanut Butter & Grape Jellies (available in milk chocolate only).
Rocky Road Sundae Bar
Regular price
$5.00
Save $-5.00
/
A Rocky Road Sundae on a stick! Chopped almonds and marshmallow enveloped in a crunchy chocolate shell.
Chocolate Coins
Regular price
$3.25
Save $-3.25
/
Strike it rich with our Chocolate Coins (1.0 oz. each) Shipped at random between everyday gold coins & seasonal chocolate coins
Pumpkin Cheesecake Meltaway
Regular price
$11.00
Sale price
$7.00
Save $4.00
/
We've swirled the decadent richness of pumpkin cheesecake into our milk chocolate meltaway for a truly luxurious treat. 8 oz
Milk Chocolate Nut Cups
Regular price
$11.00
Save $-11.00
/
Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in milk or dark.
Large Peanut Butter, Mallow, & Pretzel Cup
Regular price
$5.50
Save $-5.50
/
A perfect combination of salty and sweet! This delectable treat combines the rich, nutty goodness of peanut butter with fluffy marshmallows and the satisfying crunch of pretzels.
Milk Chocolate Nut Cups
Regular price
$11.00
Save $-11.00
/
Almond, Peanut and Filbert cups available in milk chocolate.
Nut Cups
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Almond, Peanut and Filbert Nut Cups available in Milk Chocolate or Dark Chocolate!
Tulip sucker
Regular price
$2.00
Save $-2.00
/
Milk Chocolate Tulip sucker 1.28oz
Open Rose Sucker
Regular price
$2.55
Save $-2.55
/
Milk Chocolate open rose sucker 1.6oz
“Decorated” Egg Lollipop
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$1.00
Save $2.00
/
Calling all Sponge Candy Connoisseurs!
Check out the instant savings when you purchase a Sponge Candy Connoisseurs BUNDLE BOX (online only)