Products

Specialty Chocolate
Everyday Sweets
Seasonal Candy
130 products

130 products

Quick view
Milk Chocolate Peppermint Patties
$8.00
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Pilgrim Girl
$1.40
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Raisin Bark
$16.75
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Smile Heart
$1.60
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
from $1.65
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Teddy Bear Sucker
$1.65
Quick view
Milk Chocolate with Roasted Almond Bar
$1.25
Quick view
Mini Soft-Centered Caramels
$1.65
Sold Out
Monster Marshmallow
$2.20
Quick view
Nonpareils
$5.25
Quick view
Nuts & Chewies
from $21.00
Quick view
Peanut Brittle
$5.50
Quick view
Peanut Butter Cup Bark
$21.00
Quick view
Peanut Butter Smoothie Milk Chocolate Bar
$1.25
Quick view
Pick Up Boxed Chocolates
$20.00
Quick view
Pickup Instore
$0.00
Quick view
Red Raspberry Hearts
$3.25
Quick view
Rocky Road Sundae Bar
$4.40
Quick view
Seasoned Bark
from $5.50
Quick view
Soft Creamy Caramel Milk Chocolate Bar
$1.25
stefanelli's milk chocolate peppermint patties
stefanelli's milk chocolate peppermint patties
stefanelli's milk chocolate peppermint patties
stefanelli's milk chocolate peppermint patties

Milk Chocolate Peppermint Patties

$8.00 Save $-8.00
/

Smooth, refreshing peppermint cream in a milk chocolate coating. Sold in an 8 oz. box.

Milk Chocolate Pilgrim Girl

Milk Chocolate Pilgrim Girl

$1.40 Save $-1.40
/
This solid milk chocolate Pilgrim woman is always tasteful.
stefanelli's milk chocolate raisin bark

Milk Chocolate Raisin Bark

$16.75 Save $-16.75
/

Milk chocolate bark surrounds sweet, chewy raisins. Sold per pound.

Milk Chocolate Smile Heart

Milk Chocolate Smile Heart

$1.60 Save $-1.60
/

You’ll be smiling inside after a taste of Stefanelli’s sumptuously smooth milk chocolate. (1.15 oz. ea.)

Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
stefanelli's milk chocolate sponge candy
Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
stefanelli's milk chocolate sponge candy
Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy

Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy

$1.65 Save $-1.65
/

Sponge Candy is Erie's signature candy and it's simply delicious. In other parts of the country it's also called seafoam, honeycomb or cinder toffee, or hokey pokey. Each bite offers the creamy smoothness of Stefanelli's Candies Milk Chocolate with the melt-away crunch of toffee filling.

Try to have just one piece!

Milk Chocolate Teddy Bear Sucker

Milk Chocolate Teddy Bear Sucker

$1.65 Save $-1.65
/
"Plush"-ious Stefanelli's milk chocolate for that beary special someone. (1.2 oz.)
stefanelli's milk chocolate with roasted almond bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars
stefanelli's milk chocolate with roasted almond bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars

Milk Chocolate with Roasted Almond Bar

$1.25 Save $-1.25
/
Savor Stefanelli's Milk Chocolate paired with savory roasted almonds in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. (But you'll find that's impossible!)
stefanelli's mini soft-centered caramels

Mini Soft-Centered Caramels

$1.65 Save $-1.65
/

Our premium soft-centered caramels, shrunken down for optimum snackability.

stefanelli's nonpareils

Nonpareils

$5.25 Save $-5.25
/

Plain milk chocolate discs topped with nonpareils. Available in a 4oz. box.

stefanelli's nuts and chewies

Nuts & Chewies

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/

Chewy, crunchy, and above all, tasty. Treat yourself to one or two pounds of our delicious assorted nuts, caramels, and nougats.

stefanelli's peanut brittle

Peanut Brittle

$5.50 Save $-5.50
/

Stefanelli's homemade Peanut Brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted peanuts in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4oz bag.

stefanelli's peanut butter cup bark

Peanut Butter Cup Bark

$21.00 Save $-21.00
/

Peanut butter-swirled milk chocolate bark plays host to our craveable chopped peanut butter cups. 

stefanelli's peanut butter smoothie milk chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars
stefanelli's peanut butter smoothie milk chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars

Peanut Butter Smoothie Milk Chocolate Bar

$1.25 Save $-1.25
/

Savor Stefanelli's Milk Chocolate with peanut butter in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. (But you'll find that's impossible!)

Pick Up Boxed Chocolates

Pick Up Boxed Chocolates

$20.00 Save $-20.00
/

Valentine's Day Boxed Chocolates. Store Pickup Only.

Pickup Instore

Pickup Instore

$0.00 Save $0.00
/
Red Raspberry Hearts

Red Raspberry Hearts

$3.25 Save $-3.25
/

A rugged candy exterior encloses a chewy red raspberry center in these Valentine’s delights. (6 oz. bag)

stefanelli's rocky road sundae bar

Rocky Road Sundae Bar

$4.40 Save $-4.40
/

A Rocky Road Sundae on a stick! Chopped almonds and marshmallow enveloped in a crunchy chocolate shell. 

stefanelli's seasoned bark

Seasoned Bark

$5.50 Save $-5.50
/

A 4oz bag of blended milk and dark chocolate with a hint of our special seasoning.

stefanelli's soft creamy caramel milk chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars
stefanelli's soft creamy caramel milk chocolate bar
stefanelli's chocolate bars

Soft Creamy Caramel Milk Chocolate Bar

$1.25 Save $-1.25
/

Savor Stefanelli's Milk Chocolate paired with luxuriously creamy caramel. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. (But you'll find that's impossible!)